|
Whitewater Scrubs
by Jamie McEwan
In this sequel to Willy the Scrub, the gang has
joined an after-school kayaking club. Willy seems to get
the hang of it fine, but Rufus and Clara are not doing so
well. Clara, who is one of the school's top athletes, ends
up upside-down in the rapids and develops a real fear of
getting back into the water with her kayak. Her best friend
makes sense: "Hey, you're a great athlete already. What
do you have to prove? Just quit." Clara wonders if this
sport really is "all wet."
Reviews:
Publishers Weekly, January
16, 2006
The star of Willy the Scrub and his gang of athletically
challenged friends are back to try their hand at a new sport,
this time joined by Clara, a top athlete, in Whitewater
Scrubs by Jamie McEwan, illus. by John Margeson. But
when the group signs up for an after-school kayaking club, it’s
Clara who gets cold feet. The author, a whitewater slalom racer
and an Olympic Medalist, captures some of the heart-pounding
aspects of the sport and some insiders’ lingo. Margeson’s
cartoon vignettes add a humorous touch.
School Library Journal, November,
2005
Clara, a top athlete, “was sure that anything Willy
could do, she could do better. Right?” Not when faced
with the challenging and unfamiliar sport of kayaking. Her
pals, “the
Scrubs,” convince her to try it, and she discovers she’s
terrified of the rapids. Her conflicts are true to her character.
She does not want to be a quitter or participate in a sport
in which she cannot excel, but her biggest worry is exposing
her fear. Plucky Clara resolves her problem while rescuing
Willy from hip tipping kayak. Reluctant and transitional
readers interested in sports will enjoy this story. Large type,
double spacing, and small cartoons at the beginning of each
chapter add accessibility and encouragement for beginning chapter-book
readers. A humorous sequel to Willy the Scrub, this
story stands onits own. The topic also offers a fresh kind
of sports story.
The Midwest Book Review, November,2005
In this easy-to-read chapter book sequel to “Willy the
Scrub,” Willy and the gang have joined an after-school
kayaking club. Clara has always been one of the school’s
top girl athletes, so she expects to be better than Willy, Rufus,
and Dan. After all, they were “Scrubs” on the football
team — and not so great at wrestling either. But when
Clara can’t handle the whitewater and ends up upside-down
in her kayak, she gets scared and thinks about quitting. Her
best friend Julie thinks she should walk away from kayaking
and the Scrubs. Clara has never quit anything before, but she
just can’t make up her mind. Is kayaking really “all
wet” or does she have something to prove?
Booklist, September 1, 2005
Clara was a star on the girls’ teams at school, but
now she is handing out with Willie and the other scrubs from
the football team. The foursome begins kayaking, and to Clara’s
surprise, she is not only bad at kayaking, she is scared
of it. Willie has natural ability, but he becomes frightened
enough to quit after taking a tumble in the whitewater. Clara,
who was going to quit, too, decides to stay, hoping Willie
will continue as well. Large print and plenty of cartoon-style
ink drawings make this right for kids just past easy readers.
One caveat: this is a sequel to Willy the Scrub (2004)
and it never really makes clear how Clara got together with
the boys. A couple of sentences would have helped explain
the situation. Still, there’s lots of action in this story
about a sport of a different kind.
Children's Literature
When the going gets tough, the tough get going, or do they? Clara, the protagonist,
has to find out if she can keep going when she faces some whitewater challenges.
But she is not the only one feeling that way. The fun plot focuses on Clara,
Willy, Dan, and Rufus as they learn to kayak--their alternative to going
out for a school sport. The difficult part for Clara is that she has always
been good at what she tries and now she may look like a scrub, too. Hard
work, the idea of not giving up, cooperation, respect, and truth are the
themes of the plot. They are not pointed out in a didactic way. Rather, they
come across in subtle ways which allow the characters and the readers to
learn from what is happening. The simple vocabulary and phrasing--along with
short sentences and chapters--makes reading this chapter book a successful
experience. Silly illustrations add to the entertainment by depicting Clara
and her friends in a comical way.
The Wichita Eagle, September
24, 2005
Quality beginning reader chapter books are hard to find. Whitewater
Scrubs by Jamie McEwan with illustrations by John Margeson
(Darby Creek Publishing, ages 8 and up, $14.99) is a fine
choice for reluctant readers of any age.
Willy and his friends are used to not being good at sports.
After all, they are known as the Scrubs. But Clara has always
been one of the best girl athletes. When both have troubles
with kayaking, it is Clara who is the most worried.
This 64-page book has 11 chapters of 200 to 300 words each.
McEwan has written an excellent plot with more depth of characters
than expected. His balance of narration and conversation will
engage readers. Margeson produced a small black-and-white, cartoon-style
illustration to introduce each chapter.
Willy and Clara manage to stay with kayaking by encouraging
each other. By competing in the end-of-season meet, they prove
that even "Whitewater Scrubs" can have fun.
ThisWeek Newspapers, August
4, 2005
A young girl named Clara also learns some valuable lessons
in WhitewaterScrubs (Darby Creek Publishing,
$14.99, 63 pages), written by Jamie McEwan and illustrated by
John Margeson. Clara learns the value of persistence and focus.
This chapter book for beginning readers features an athletic
girl who is used to excelling in athletic undertakings. Then
she tries kayaking.
The team consists mostly of boys and Clara soon finds she
isn't dominating as easily as she's accustomed to in other sports.
Clara is tempted to quit and wishes she'd gone out for another
sport. She has to overcome not only her own learning curve,
but also a good deal of fear. That fear is compounded when she
capsizes her kayak in frigid white water and must remember how
to free herself from her kayak and get to the surface.
Her temptation to drop the sport is soon tested by her mounting
anger and frustration with her own performance. Soon she's making
lists -- weighing the consequences and implications of sticking
it out or quitting.
Whitewater Scrubs is a sequel to McEwan's Willy
the Scrub.
|